Advocate General Proposes Setting Aside the General Court’s Annulment of a EUR 1.5 Billion Fine Imposed for Abuse of a Dominant Position

An Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European Union (“CJEU”) has proposed that the Court of Justice set aside the General Court’s judgment annulling the decision of the European Commission (“Commission”) to impose a fine of almost EUR 1.5 billion on a technology company. The press release published by the CJEU on 12 November 2026 provides details of the Opinion delivered in Case C-826/24 P.

The Opinion addresses the following key issues:

  • The case concerns contractual clauses applied by the company concerned to website operators using its online search advertising intermediation service.
  • The exclusivity, placement and prior authorisation clauses in the agreements concluded with these operators restricted or prohibited the display of search advertisements from competing services. In its decision of March 2019, the Commission found that these clauses had infringed Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union between 2006 and 2016 and constituted a single and continuous infringement.
  • By its judgment of 18 September 2024 in Case T-334/19, the General Court annulled the decision on the ground that the duration of the contractual relationships had not been adequately examined. As a result, exclusionary effects were not considered to have been demonstrated.
  • While the duration of contractual commitments is one of the criteria established in the case law of the Court of Justice for assessing exclusionary effects, the Opinion emphasises that this criterion does not require a detailed analysis of each individual contract. It is sufficient, in principle, for the relevant agreements to be assessed cumulatively in light of their duration, content and application.
  • According to the Opinion, the Commission’s overall assessment, which relied on average values where appropriate, has satisfied these requirements. Thus, the General Court was found to have imposed excessive requirements and to have called into question its own finding that the clauses were capable of producing exclusionary effects.
  • The Advocate General concluded that the General Court had erred in law, including in finding that the infringements could not constitute a single and continuous infringement. The Advocate General proposed that the judgment be set aside and that the case be referred back to the General Court for examination of the remaining pleas, including the objections of the company concerned to the amount of the fine.
  • The Advocate General further considers that the fine should, in any event, be reduced, as the General Court’s findings concerning the lack of demonstrated exclusionary effects in 2016 have not been challenged.

The Opinion is not binding on the Court of Justice, which will deliver its judgment at a later date.

You can access the full text of the press release here.

Kind regards,
Zumbul Attorneys-at-Law
info@zumbul.av.tr

All information and documents published on our website have been prepared by Zümbül Law and Consultancy solely for general informational purposes, taking into consideration the Attorneyship Law, other applicable legislation and the Professional Rules of the Turkish Union of Bar Associations. These publications are not intended for advertising and/or commercial purposes. All information and documents available on our website are of a general nature. No representation or warranty is made as to the completeness, accuracy, currency or reliability of such publications. The information and documents provided on our website should not be relied upon or acted upon without first consulting a lawyer or other qualified professional.The links included in our website publications have been obtained from publicly available sources and are provided solely to facilitate visitors’ access to additional information and documents. The inclusion of such links does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement of the individuals, institutions or organisations to which they refer. The publications on our website do not constitute legal advice under any circumstances, nor does access to our website or any communication through it, in itself, establish an attorney-client relationship between Zümbül Law and Consultancy and any visitor to the website.